Sarah Lolley
  • Mailbox Missions
  • NDG Walks
  • What's New
  • Intro to Cryptic Crosswords
  • CBC/QWF Writer-in-Residence
  • Contact Me
  • Puzzle Tutorial
  • Practice Puzzles

Learning By Doing

5/26/2014

3 Comments

 
PictureMy first attempts at setting involved pencils and graph paper.
My father, a born engineer, has spent his entire life taking things apart in order to figure out how they work. At fourteen, he attached wheels to a push lawnmower and made his own go-cart. At nineteen, he deconstructed and rebuilt an air compressor. When I was four, he built an entire car (The Lolley Trolley) from scratch.



To my father, the world is a collection of systems whose mysteries are one careful disassembly away from being revealed.
I assumed that this instinct had just passed me by. Unlike my sister, the architect, or my brother who designs video games, I've never cared about the inner workings of things.

Then I started solving cryptic crosswords. Out of nowhere, that engineering curiosity kicked in. No sooner had I gotten the hang of solving the puzzles than I wanted to figure out how to make one myself.
Picture
The Lolley Trolley, circa 1981.
I wanted to figure out what makes a good puzzle tick.

But despite searching high and low for the rules that govern the setting of cryptics, I came up empty-handed. I could find no books or blogs on the subject; just a small community of cryptic crossword aficionados on twitter who occasionally share clues. Too impatient to wait for the right lesson to come along, I sat down with a few Fraser Simpson puzzles, a coffee, and my newfound engineer's curiosity, and set to work figuring out for myself how his grids and clues are structured.
Picture
The first cryptic crossword I ever made. Note the overabundance of black space and the lack of symmetry. After designing it with pencil and paper, I drew it up using Microsoft Word.
I have made twenty puzzles since then. Interestingly, the more I strive to learn, the more I connect with people who can help. For example, a veteran setter I found on twitter turned me on to puzzle-making software. (Making my first few puzzles with graph paper, a pencil, and a heavy-duty eraser was incredibly arduous.) My question about minimum answer length was also recently answered: although Fraser Simpson's shortest is four letters, this cannot be a universal rule because I recently saw a clue from The Times with a three-letter answer.

It can be frustrating, learning all this in dribs and drabs. As with writing, I often wish I could just read a comprehensive "how-to" manual and not waste my time with all the fumbling in the dark. But this is what learning by doing is all about. You pop the hood, check out what's inside, figure out the unique and essential role that each part plays, then apply that knowledge to your own project. It might take a while but eventually, when you turn the key, you are rewarded with the low purr of victory.
3 Comments
James Lolley
5/27/2014 12:30:22 am

Love it!

Reply
Crypticrochet link
6/9/2014 12:19:46 pm

We have many similarities. Although I admit my passion for cryptics (and crochet) are used to avoid my insecurity around my writing. The new chew toy, the hearty distraction.The story will always be waiting.

If you've not read David Astle's books yet, I highly recommend them. There's also a lot of compilers on the Cryptic Crossword Society facebook page who are more than willing to talk rules of compiling. For me, I still struggle to solve, but every so often a clue pops into my head. How can it be avoided?

Enjoy your victories, may they be many,

Reply
Faten
4/19/2016 06:52:55 am

I made my first grid using pencil and paper too. Chose the words, deleted, changed, retried until everything fit in. It took a while but was totally worth it, definitely not a convenient method for one who makes many grids, but it gives a great satisfaction when its done, especially if the solvers enjoy it. Enjoyed reading this article, very nice thanks for sharing.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    About Sarah

    I'm a writer, adventurer, amateur setter of cryptic crosswords, lover of "ah-ha!" moments, and exhausted mom.

    Archives

    November 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    April 2019
    May 2018
    April 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    March 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    February 2016
    December 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    December 2013

    Categories

    All
    Accents
    Acrostics
    Amazement
    Bob Dylan
    Books
    Brain
    Certainty
    Choose Your Own Adventure
    Chris Hadfield
    Christmas
    Coincidence
    Creativity
    Cryptic Crossword Tutorial
    Editing Puzzles
    ELLE Magazine
    Epiphany
    Escape Room
    Family
    Finding Your Way
    Fraser Simpson
    Globe And Mail
    Group Solving
    Hero
    Hidden Messages
    Homophone Clues
    Horcrux
    Leonard Cohen
    Love
    Making Mistakes
    Maps
    Marriage
    Memory
    #MeToo
    Momentum
    Montreal Review Of Books
    Motherhood
    Music
    Mystery
    Nabokov
    Natural Phenomena
    Oliver Sacks
    Personal Essay
    Personalized Cryptics
    Politics
    Puzzles In Print
    Renovation
    Secrets
    Setting Puzzles
    The Committee Of Sleep
    The Coriolis Effect
    Travel
    Wes Anderson
    Wordplay
    Writer-in-Residence
    Writing
    Yoga

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.