Sarah Lolley
  • Mailbox Missions
  • NDG Walks
  • What's New
  • Intro to Cryptic Crosswords
  • CBC/QWF Writer-in-Residence
  • Contact Me
  • Puzzle Tutorial
  • Practice Puzzles

Measure Twice, Cryptic Once

1/9/2017

4 Comments

 
PictureFiguring out how to fit everything into the small master bathroom.
Have you ever renovated?

We spent the entire fall in the throes of a major house reno. It was tons of fun, everything worked out well, and I learned a great deal. The most important lesson was the golden rule of construction: measure twice and cut once
.

​This is smart advice to take literally but it's also a wise principle to apply more generally. Spend a lot of time planning. Review your work. 
There will be fewer mistakes and when surprises do crop up, you'll be better prepared to deal with them.

Planning carefully is key to producing a good cryptic crossword puzzle, which is why I was so surprised this past Saturday when there was a mistake in Fraser Simpson's cryptic crossword in the Globe and Mail.
If you were stumped by the puzzle and don't know why, that might have been the cause. In the bottom left-hand corner of the grid, the following two clues were meant to intersect, the last letter of the Down clue being the first letter of the Across clue. But they didn't match:
Picture
29 Across: Doctor with excellent way of selling fear (5)

23 Down: Obligation surrounding university introduction (5)

These are straightforward clues. The first is DR+E+Ad and the second is DEB(U)T. But when I started fitting in the rest of the clues, it became clear that "Debut" was problematic. The answer for 23 Across confirmed it.

Picture
Mistakes are rare in Fraser Simpson's puzzles (although there was another one just a few weeks back when "sinister" was used to clue "R" when really it should have given "L"). I doubted myself for a little while when I first suspected this mistake.

Then I wondered if Fraser Simpson had started with DEBUT in an early draft of the puzzle, then, as he developed it more, intended for DEBUT to be turned upside-down but never made the change in the clues.

What clue would you write for TUBED? "Climbing first step, rode the London subway? (5)" is the best I can manage.

​I'm curious to see if the mistake will be acknowledged in next Saturday's solutions. But I'm even more curious to know something I'll never find out: what clue for TUBED would, had it been measured twice, made the Fraser Simpson cut.

4 Comments
Franca
1/12/2017 08:00:14 am

Hey, thanks for this! My husband and I were likewise confused by the error.

Reply
Sarah
1/12/2017 10:32:22 am

Hi Franca, I'm glad it was helpful!

Reply
Jack
1/15/2017 08:04:19 am

I was also puzzled by this. The solution in yesterday's G&M simply said 23 across = trainable, 23 down = debut, with no acknowledgement of the mistake.

Reply
John
4/11/2017 04:33:45 pm

Not a mistake, as in the grid, this week (April 08, 2017) but the construction of the 1 Down clue is poor and therefore misleading.
The error relates to the logic concept that all elephants are animals but not all animals are elephants.
Clue, as written: "Shortages leave a lasting mark on Regina and Saskatoon (10)".
Answer: Scarcities.

Clue should read: " Shortages leave a lasting mark on Regina and Saskatoon, for example (10)".

In other words, Regina and Saskatoon are cities but cities are not necessarily Regina and Saskatoon.
Setters get over this issue by including "for example" or "say", etc. in the clue.

Fraser has repeatedly demonstrated that he is very particular about his clue accuracy. If he wasn't (as in the case of the Globe's now pitiful daily puzzle setters), his errors, few as they are, would pass without remark.
Keep up the good work, Fraser.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    About Sarah

    I'm a writer, adventurer, amateur setter of cryptic crosswords, lover of "ah-ha!" moments, and exhausted mom.

    Archives

    November 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    April 2019
    May 2018
    April 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    March 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    February 2016
    December 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    December 2013

    Categories

    All
    Accents
    Acrostics
    Amazement
    Bob Dylan
    Books
    Brain
    Certainty
    Choose Your Own Adventure
    Chris Hadfield
    Christmas
    Coincidence
    Creativity
    Cryptic Crossword Tutorial
    Editing Puzzles
    ELLE Magazine
    Epiphany
    Escape Room
    Family
    Finding Your Way
    Fraser Simpson
    Globe And Mail
    Group Solving
    Hero
    Hidden Messages
    Homophone Clues
    Horcrux
    Leonard Cohen
    Love
    Making Mistakes
    Maps
    Marriage
    Memory
    #MeToo
    Momentum
    Montreal Review Of Books
    Motherhood
    Music
    Mystery
    Nabokov
    Natural Phenomena
    Oliver Sacks
    Personal Essay
    Personalized Cryptics
    Politics
    Puzzles In Print
    Renovation
    Secrets
    Setting Puzzles
    The Committee Of Sleep
    The Coriolis Effect
    Travel
    Wes Anderson
    Wordplay
    Writer-in-Residence
    Writing
    Yoga

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.